Alone Among the Crowd: Navigating Men's Mental Health in the Holiday Season
- Mark Pitcher
- 6 days ago
- 15 min read
Elias tightened his grip on two shopping bags as he stood by the mall's giant Christmas tree, its lights flickering through the evening gloom. Around him, people laughed and posed for photos under garlands of pine and candy canes. On the outside, he looked calm, a man finishing holiday errands after work. But inside his chest felt heavy, as if sinking through holiday cheer into something quiet and gray. He had been sleeping only in fragments, stomach fluttering with a joyless dread each morning. When friends asked how he was, he said with a practiced smile that he was "good, just busy," because explaining the tightness in his chest felt impossible. Even surrounded by family – his partner, their daughter, brothers on the phone – he felt a subtle disconnection, an emotional distance he could not bridge. It was as if he were watching life happen at a remove, loved by others yet somehow always alone.
This is not a flaw, nor an excuse, but a profoundly human experience – one that many men share in silence. Holiday seasons weave together nostalgia, grief, obligation and hope, and for many men, the weight of those emotions can be hard to bear without support. This article is for men like Elias – fathers and sons, brothers and friends – who carry unseen burdens yet rarely speak of them. It is also for anyone who cares about men in their lives: to understand that suffering in silence is neither inevitable nor deserved. By acknowledging how cultural expectations and seasonal stress can amplify loneliness, we can begin to chart paths toward healing and connection.
The Landscape of Holiday Loneliness: What the Data Reveal
Even young men can experience loneliness sharply. The WHO's recent report on social connection highlights that roughly 1 in 6 people worldwide experience loneliness (World Health Organization [WHO], 2025), underscoring the significant toll it takes on health and well-being. Anecdotally, the data are striking: a BBC Science Focus Magazine article notes that "Teenagers are some of the loneliest people in society" (Taylor, 2022), illustrating that isolation does not respect age. In Canada, surveys echo these findings in male populations. For example, Statistics Canada reports that only about half of Canadian men rate their mental health as excellent or very good (Statistics Canada, 2023), with the rest feeling merely "okay" or worse. Married men and those living with family fare better – 55% of partnered men reported excellent mental health versus 43% of unpartnered men (Statistics Canada, 2023) – highlighting how connection can buoy well-being. Crucially, support matters: 70% of men said they "always or often" have someone to count on, and these men were far more likely to report strong mental health (55% excellent) than those without such support (38%) (Statistics Canada, 2023).
Seasonal stress adds to this emotional burden. Canadians experience reduced daylight and longer nights in winter, which can disrupt circadian rhythms and sap serotonin, contributing to what is often called the "winter blues." In fact, about 15% of Canadians report at least mild seasonal depression and 2–3% meet criteria for complete Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) (Amirault, 2020). In Alberta or other northern regions, the holiday "turn down" of daylight can literally mirror an emotional turn inward. At the same time, holiday expectations rise: to celebrate with cheer, to provide gifts, to host dinners – roles many men feel pressure to fulfill. These external demands and internal stresses can collide. Research suggests that men tend to internalize cultural messages about strength and self-reliance, which makes admitting difficulty feel like failure (Mayo Clinic, 2025). Indeed, men are significantly more likely than women to hide mental health struggles and avoid seeking help. (For example, a Canadian survey found young men were among the least likely to seek professional help despite high levels of distress.) This silence compounds problems.
The data remind us that holiday loneliness among men is not just "in someone's head." It is a public health concern. Loneliness itself is linked to higher rates of depression, anxiety, and even physical illness (World Health Organization [WHO], 2025). Understanding the numbers helps break the spell of stigma: seeing that many men feel isolated can make it easier to admit we're not alone in feeling it. Acknowledging these patterns is the first step toward changing them.
Cultural Pressures: Why Men Suffer in Silence
Holiday films and cards often show men as the calm anchors of the family – the smiling father assembling toys in the night, the provider quietly hanging lights on the house. Those warm portrayals omit the turbulence beneath the surface. Our culture still tells a story that "real men" must be uncomplaining, self-sufficient, and always in control. From boyhood onward, many of us hear phrases like "man up" or "stop whining," subtly teaching that emotions are a weakness. Over time, this training shrinks emotional vocabulary. A notable example comes from developmental psychology: when boys are very young, they often describe friendships as intimate, but by mid-adolescence, they brush off closeness with humour and bravado (Taylor, 2022).
This emotional suppression is not the fault of any individual man; it is the legacy of a narrow ideal of masculinity. Psychologists call the conflict felt by modern men "role strain" – the stress of trying to fit human complexity into a rigid mould of toughness and stoicism. During the holidays, those pressures intensify. A man may feel he must hide grief or exhaustion so as not to "ruin" the festivities for others. He may believe that showing sadness is ungrateful or burdensome to the family. Unfortunately, suppressing feelings doesn't make them disappear – it often amplifies them in isolation.
Studies consistently find that men, across cultures, are much less likely than women to talk about personal troubles with friends or family. Instead, many default to coping strategies like overworking, drinking, or withdrawing, which only deepen the cycle of loneliness. In this context, it's crucial to redefine strength. Vulnerability does not undermine a man's worth; it affirms it. In fact, researchers of positive masculinity emphasize that real resilience comes from wholeness – acknowledging needs and seeking support is as brave and healthy as any traditional masculine feat. True strength might look like picking up the phone to call a brother and saying, "I'm not doing so well," or admitting to oneself, "Today I am feeling overwhelmed." As one researcher notes, placing value on connection and empathy is not a break from manhood, but an evolution of it.
By widening the definition of masculinity to include emotional honesty, we allow men to care for themselves and those around them honestly. This holiday season, let's celebrate the idea that asking for support is a sign of integrity, not weakness.
Emotional Literacy: A Skill, not a Personality Trait
One reason holiday emotions catch men off-guard is a lack of emotional literacy – that is, the learned ability to recognize and name feelings. Boys often grow up being rewarded for covering up hurt or frustration. Over the years, feelings of grief or anxiety can feel foreign and "not worth mentioning." Without words to describe their inner state, men may struggle to explain what's wrong, even to themselves.
The good news is that emotional literacy can be developed at any age. Neuroscience shows that naming an emotion actually helps regulate it: saying "I feel anxious" engages brain regions that calm the amygdala, reducing raw stress responses (Lieberman et al., 2007). In practice, this means when Elias thinks, "I'm feeling low today," he isn't complaining – he is grounding himself and diffusing his fear. During holidays, emotions mix in complex ways: nostalgia blurs with loss, joy with exhaustion. Being able to label these feelings with simple words can offer a powerful compass. For example, taking a minute to name "I'm missing Dad right now" can relieve the unnamed tension.
Increasingly, public figures and community leaders are modelling this openness. From athletes speaking about anxiety to friends admitting they are exhausted, every act of sharing truth chips away at stigma. It signals that men's inner lives matter. Indeed, leading psychologists stress that expressing emotions is part of healthy human functioning – it has nothing to do with failing gender expectations. As one man's advocate puts it, caring for your emotional health is entirely compatible with being a strong man. In fact, it is one of the most powerful strengths we can cultivate.
Practical Embodiment: Tools for Navigating the Season
Understanding these issues is vital, but it's only the start. Real change happens when knowledge meets action – when men practice small, concrete acts of self-care. The following strategies are grounded in research and designed to engage the whole person – body, mind, and spirit – in line with a holistic approach to masculinity. None of them requires special equipment or a perfect schedule, just a willingness to experiment. Each practice is an invitation, not a demand for instant transformation.
Box Breathing (4–4–4–4): This simple breathing exercise activates the body's relaxation response. It has been used by athletes, service members, and therapists alike. Try this before a holiday gathering or when stress creeps in. Inhale through your nose for 4 seconds, hold the breath for 4 seconds, exhale slowly for 4 seconds, then pause and hold your breath for 4 seconds. Repeat this cycle two or three times. The deliberate rhythm tells your nervous system it's okay to calm down, softening anxiety.
Mindful Pause Before a Social Event: A minute of mindful grounding can make a big difference in a busy season. Stand for a moment and notice your feet on the floor or touch a warm mug of coffee in your hands. Take three slow, deep breaths, paying attention to how your body feels. This quick pause reconnects you with the present moment and your own needs, which helps prevent overwhelm when you step into a room full of people and chatter.
The Winter Walk Ritual: Even a brief exposure to nature can reset the mind. Research shows that spending 20–30 minutes outdoors in a green or natural setting significantly lowers cortisol (the stress hormone) (Harvard Health, 2019). A brisk walk before or after work lets you breathe fresh air, stretch your legs, and clear mental clutter. It might mean simply circling the neighbourhood under streetlights, but notice the quiet rhythm of your steps and the cool air on your face. Many men find that these short walks break cycles of rumination and leave them more centred.
Micro-Movement Practice: You don't need an hour-long gym session to reap the mental benefits of exercise. Even a few push-ups, a short yoga sequence, or a quick set of stretches at home can elevate your mood. Physical movement releases endorphins, the brain's natural "feel-good" chemicals (Mayo Clinic, 2025). Think of it as a brief reminder that your body is alive and supporting you. These mini workouts can be woven into the day – perhaps after finishing a work email or before shifting tasks – as a signal to your brain that you deserve care.
Nightly Gratitude Reflection: It might sound simple, but ending the day by writing down two or three positive things is scientifically proven to shift focus from stress to blessing. In experiments, people who kept brief gratitude journals reported higher positive mood and life satisfaction than those who didn't (Emmons and McCullough, 2003). At bedtime, jot down small wins or pleasant moments from the day – a good conversation, a funny memory, the warmth of family. Over time, this practice trains your mind to notice the good even amid busyness, countering the mind's natural tendency to fixate on problems.
One Honest Check-In: Schedule one meaningful connection each week. It could be a phone call, a coffee date, or even a text exchange – however you feel comfortable. Men may find it hard to start these conversations, but remember, people want to support you. (In fact, Statistics Canada found that 70% of men said they always have someone to count on (Statistics Canada, 2023).) Your friend or brother may be feeling similarly isolated but fearful of reaching out too. Initiating a candid "How are you really doing?" can open the door to greater closeness for both of you. No need for a dramatic confession; even saying "I'm actually a bit overwhelmed" can be enough to break the ice. Each time you share honestly, you build a bridge not just for yourself but for others who silently wait for permission to do the same.
Call to Brotherhood: No Man Left Behind
Men struggling in silence often appear calm on the outside, yet behind closed doors, they may feel profoundly alone. The image above captures a scene familiar to many: a man standing in an empty room, gazing out the window. He is surrounded by the trappings of life – a computer, a comfortable chair – but alone in experience. Data reinforce how critical even small connections are: in one Canadian survey, over half (55%) of men who said they "always have someone to count on" reported excellent mental health, compared to only 38% of those without such support (Statistics Canada, 2023). These numbers tell a clear story: men need friends and family, just like anyone else.
The good news is that forming bonds doesn't require massive effort or vulnerability beyond one's comfort zone. Brotherhood can be built with everyday gestures: a coffee with an old friend, a walk with a coworker, a text check-in to a neighbour. These moments of presence strengthen ties. Community groups and men's circles across Canada already harness this power by creating spaces for conversation and shared activities. Whether in Indigenous winter gatherings of storytelling and community, local health meetups, sports teams, or online forums, what matters is showing up authentically. You don't need to spout your life story – sometimes laughter over a shared game or advice on coping is enough to knit closeness.
Positive friendships and group support improve resilience, reduce the risk of depression, and even promote physical health. In fact, people in close-knit groups often see benefits like those of healthy exercise and diet. The simple act of knowing someone cares – of being able to say, "That really hurt," or "I'm proud of you" – can lift a significant weight off one's heart. When men gather, they model to each other that emotions and struggles are normal. Every honest conversation chips away at loneliness. Brotherhood doesn't solve all problems, but it ensures no man must struggle alone. It reminds us that, even in winter's darkness, others will listen and hold the light for us.
Light Returning
Winter has its own rhythm and meaning across cultures. Many traditions view the long nights as a time for rest, reflection and renewal. As one winter customs guide notes, "With its long nights and slower pace, winter often invites introspection and moments of pause" (TransPerfect, 2025). Firesides, candlelit gatherings and cozy blankets are not just clichés; they echo ancient wisdom that in the season's stillness, we can find comfort and togetherness. In Finland, they practice hygge, creating warmth and joy in the darkness. In Japan, winter festivals celebrate light and community with ice sculptures and shared warmth. Even cultures without snow celebrate winter as a time of gratitude and hope. These stories remind us: winter is not only a trial to survive, but a season in which care and community flourish.
Imagine Elias again, weeks after that evening at the mall. It's late December, and snow is falling gently around his backyard. He sits on the porch steps after putting his daughter to bed, wrapped in a blanket with a mug of tea. Inside, he hears his family laughing together. The heaviness in his chest is still there, but softer now. A few days ago, he had picked up the phone and said to his brother, "I'm not sure what's wrong, but this season feels really heavy." His brother's reply was quite understanding: "Yeah, man, I feel it too. Want to talk?" That conversation unlocked something. Since then, Elias has been taking short morning walks when the world is still, practicing box breathing at night, and each evening jotting down one or two good things from the day. These small acts did not erase his pain, but they softened it. They reminded him he was not alone and that he deserved care as much as anyone else.
Elias watches the snow gather on the porch light, each exhale fogging in the cold. He feels a quiet peace kindling within him. He is still navigating grief and stress – but now he has tools, connections, and permission to feel. The holidays are complicated, yes, but they no longer swallow him.
This gentle peace is the message of hope we share. Healing doesn't always come in a sudden burst. Sometimes it comes through a deep breath, a kind word from a friend, a memory that makes us smile, or the simple act of noticing falling snow. You deserve those moments of peace. You deserve support. If the holidays feel heavy, remember that reaching out to yourself and others is one of the most courageous and human things you can do. Take a step toward connection this week – a walk, a conversation, a quiet moment with a friend or with yourself. Not out of indulgence, but out of necessity and honour. Because no man should have to walk through winter alone.
References
Amirault, Sarah. (2020, December 31). Seasonal Affective Disorder (Depression with Seasonal Pattern). Canadian Psychological Association [CPA] "Psychology Works" Fact Sheet, retrieved from https://cpa.ca/psychology-works-fact-sheet-seasonal-affective-disorder-depression-with-seasonal-pattern/.
Berman, Marc G.; Jonides, John; and Kaplan, Stephen. (2008). The Cognitive Benefits of Interacting with Nature. Psychological Science 19(12), 1207–1212.
Carron, Albert V.; and Brawley, Lawrence R. (2000). Cohesion: Conceptual and Measurement Issues. Small Group Research, 31(1), 89-106.
Cohen, Sheldon. (2004). Social Relationships and Health. American Psychologist 59(8), 676-684.
Di Bianca, Michael; Martin, Nicholas G.; and Mahalik, James R. (2023). Every Guy Needs His Team: The Promise of Peer-Led Mentoring Groups for College Men. Journal of American College Health, 71(2), 468-478.
Emmons, Robert A., and McCullough, Michael E. (2003). Counting Blessings Versus Burdens: An Experimental Investigation of Gratitude and Subjective Well-Being. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(2), 377–389.
Enggasser, Justin L.; and Young, Michael A. (2007). Cognitive Vulnerability to Depression in Seasonal Affective Disorder: Predicting Mood and Cognitive Symptoms in Individuals with Seasonal Vegetative Changes. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 31(1), 3-21.
Harvard Health Publishing. (2019, July 1). A 20-Minute Nature Break Relieves Stress. Retrieved from https://www.health.harvard.edu/mind-and-mood/a-20-minute-nature-break-relieves-stress.
Hawkley, Louise C.; and Cacioppo, John T. (2010). Loneliness Matters: A Theoretical and Empirical Review of Consequences and Mechanisms. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 40(2), 218-227.
Izenstark, Dina; Ravindran, Niyantri. (2023). Associations Between Childhood Family‐Based Nature Activities and Family Relationship Quality in Emerging Adulthood. Family Relations, 72(3), 1276-1291.
Lieberman, Matthew D.; Eisenberger, Naomi I.; Crockett, Molly J.; Tom, Sabrina M.; Pfeifer, Jennifer H.; and Way, Baldwin M. (2007). Putting Feelings into Words: Affect Labeling Disrupts Amygdala Activity in Response to Affective Stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428.
Mayo Clinic. (2025, September 19). Exercise and Stress: Get Moving to Manage Stress. Retrieved from https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/stress-management/in-depth/exercise-and-stress/art-20044469.
McQuaid, Robyn Jane; Bombay, Amy; McInnis, Opal Arilla; Humeny, Courtney; Matheson, Kimberly; and Anisman, Hymie. (2017). Suicide Ideation and Attempts among First Nations Peoples Living On-Reserve in Canada: The Intergenerational and Cumulative Effects of Indian Residential Schools. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 62(6), 422-430.
Statistics Canada. (2022, January 26). You Are Not Alone. Retrieved from https://www.statcan.gc.ca/o1/en/plus/274-you-are-not-alone
Statistics Canada. (2023, June 12). Men's Mental Health: How are Canadian Men doing? Retrieved from https://www.statcan.gc.ca/o1/en/plus/3811-mens-mental-health-how-are-canadian-men-doing.
Taylor, Ian. (2022, November 11). How Loneliness is Killing Men: Why Mates are a Kind of Medicine. BBC Science Focus, retrieved from https://www.sciencefocus.com/science/how-loneliness-is-killing-men.
Thompson, Edward H.; and Langendoerfer, Kaitlyn Barnes. (2016). Older Men's Blueprint for "Being a Man". Men and Masculinities, 19(2), 119-147.
TransPerfect. (2025, January 25). Winter Traditions and Symbolism Across Cultures. Retrieved from https://www.transperfect.com/blog/winter-traditions-and-symbolism-across-cultures.
World Health Organization [WHO]. (2025, June 30). Social Connection Linked to Improved Health and Reduced Risk of Early Death. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/news/item/30-06-2025-social-connection-linked-to-improved-heath-and-reduced-risk-of-early-death.
© Citation:
Pitcher, E. Mark. (2025, December 8). Alone Among the Crowd: Navigating Men's Mental Health in the Holiday Season. Beyond Brotherhood. https://www.beyondbrotherhood.ca/post/alone-among-the-crowd-navigating-men-s-mental-health-in-the-holiday-season.
About the Author
Mark Pitcher lives where the mountains keep their oldest promises—in a valley deep in the Canadian Rockies, where glacier-fed waters carve poetry into stone and night skies burn with a silence so vast it feels like truth speaking.
Half the year, he calls this wilderness home—no paved roads. No lights. No noise but the heartbeat of the land.
It is here—between two ancient peaks, in the hush of untouched forest—that Mark's soul was reforged in the fires of loss and meaning.
Because his journey did not begin with peace, it started with a crack in the universe.
On January 3, 2024, when his beloved Maggie left this world, Mark stood at the edge of unthinkable heartbreak. And in that devastating stillness, he offered a vow to the sky: "Find community. Find purpose."
Those words didn't just echo—they opened something. Something fierce. Something ancient. Something that refused to let him sink into the dark.
From that vow, the first spark of Beyond Brotherhood leapt to life—a spark that would become a fire strong enough to warm other grieving souls, lost souls, searching souls, warrior souls who had forgotten the sound of their own heartbeat. Mark walked into his sorrow and came out carrying a torch.
Today, he stands as a bridge between two worlds: the untamed wilderness that shapes him, and the global brotherhoods that inspire him—WYLDMen, MDI, Connect'd Men, Illuman, Man-Aligned, Sacred Sons, UNcivilized Nation, and The Strenuous Life.
He walks among these circles as a brother beside—a man who has knelt in the ashes and risen with a purpose that hums like thunder beneath his ribs.
Mark's teachings are a constellation of old and new: Viktor Frankl's pursuit of meaning, Indigenous land teachings, the cold bite of resilience training, the quiet medicine of Shinrin-yoku, the flowing strength of Qigong, the psychology of modern brotherhood, and the fierce ethics of the warrior who knows compassion is a weapon of liberation.
He is a student of Spiritual Care at St. Stephen's College and a seeker of Indigenous truth and reconciliation at the University of Calgary. He is training to guide others into the healing arms of the forest and cold water.
But titles barely touch him. Mark Pitcher is a man rebuilt in the open—a man who lets grief speak so others can let their truth breathe. A guide. A mentor. A storyteller whose voice feels like a compass. A wilderness warrior who carries warmth like a fire in the night. A man who says, "You don't have to walk this alone. None of us does."
His presence does something to people—it steadies them, softens them, reminds them of a primal belonging they have long forgotten.
Beyond Brotherhood is the living proof of his promise: a sanctuary shaped by grief, courage, and unwavering love—a place where men remember who they are, who they were and who they can still become.
Mark's upcoming book will dive even deeper into the rise of wilderness-led masculinity—the rebirth of brotherhood in a fractured world, the return of men to purpose, connection, and meaning.
And if your heart is thundering as you read this—good.
That's the signal.
That's the call.
Mark extends his hand to you with the warmth of a fire in winter: You belong here.
Your story belongs here. Your strength belongs here. Walk with him. Into the wilderness. Into the circle. Into the life that's been waiting for you.
The journey is only beginning—and Mark is already at the trailhead, looking back with a smile that says: "Brother, you're right on time."
Comments